2016 BAFTA 2017 Nominee film General Release

I, Daniel Blake | Review

In a searing indictment of austerity Britain, Loach exposes the struggle to retain dignity and humanity with equal bluntness and affection.

Dir. Ken Loach

Screenplay. Paul Laverty

Britain, 2016

It must be difficult for Damian Green MP, the current Work and Pension Secretary, to defend his predecessor’s legacy. No wonder he is so defensive when discussing I, Daniel Blake, dismissing it as a mere “work of fiction that bears no relation to the modern benefits system” and defaming director Ken Loach as being “monstrously unfair to job centre staff”. Not only has Green, as he has openly admitted, clearly not seen the film, but has not been living in the same Britain as those exposed to the cruel joke of what is ironically called the welfare system.  Loach and writer Paul Laverty’s latest collaboration portray the consequences of the Coalition’s austerity politics with a sweeping indictment of the privatisation of benefit assessmentsocial cleansing, wide-spread use of food banks and the devastating effects of benefit sanctions. In bringing these issues to the screen with characteristic humour but unswerving bleakness, I, Daniel Blake is a sharp, humane corrective to the ‘scroungers and shirkers’ narrative promoted to justify austerity Britain.

2717
Hayley Squire’s performance is powerful but incredibly difficult to watch, as she deftly shows Katie’s increasing tiredness, emaciation but also implacable strength. 

When recent widower and joiner by trade, Daniel Blake (Dave Johns), is diagnosed with a heart condition making him unable to work, he attempts to claim Employment and Support Allowance. However, assessed by a private company on behalf of the DWP, he is ruled fit-to-work and enters unprepared into the Kafkaesque benefits system. He soon discovers the ageist processes of internet application and the disembodied, unaccountable control of the ‘decision-maker’ via elongated telephone calls. In a fateful encounter, Blake meets fraught but resolute single parent of two, Katie (Hayley Squires), a social exile from London who is trying desperately to make Newcastle a ‘home if it’s the last thing [she] does’. The two soon find their lives intertwined as they rely on each other for the social and emotional support so lacking from the state services they’re dependent on. Loach and Laverty are concerned with the dehumanising effects of austerity, where daily precarity and the state’s callous indifference erode meaningful relationships, community-spirit and conscience. Despite Green’s accusations, Laverty portrays how the job-centre bureaucracy strips compassion from the otherwise well-meaning staff, centring around the meek Ann (Kate Rutter). At constant risk are not only the characters physical survival. but more importantly their sense of self-respect and recognition as citizens, not pariahs, of the society.

Johns plays the eponymous Blake with great humour and dignity, though never deigns to being a victim we pity or laugh at. Rather, John makes us empathise with Blake’s bewilderment and frustration with the job centre application and the atomising forces that have changed his community. Calling on his comedic talents, Johns forces us to laugh in step with Blake’s plain-speaking observations (a wonderful scene at a CV-writing workshop exemplifies this). We stand firmly with Blake though concern grows throughout the film whether his damaged heart will, both medically and emotionally, hold out under the growing pressures. Squires’ understated performance is powerful but incredibly difficult to watch, as she deftly shows Katie’s increasing tiredness, emaciation but also implacable strength. Again, despite Blake’s paternal-like presence in her life, she refuses to be a victim to her circumstances. Loach and Laverty give both characters a fragility but determination, of self-worth in their defiance and the acts of kindness they display to each other and those around them. When the social fabric has collapsed, what else is left?

ichdanielblake03
As with Blake’s act of protest in the film, I, Daniel Blake is an assertion of person-hood, a cry against the state forces that are denigrating thousands of people and a call to recognise their dignity. 

Loach and cinematographer Robbie Ryan’s un-elaborate, minimalist style doesn’t encroach on the actors’ naturalistic performances. Instead, we feel as if we are observers to the daily experience of the job centre, the food bank, the toil of finding unemployment. There are few embellishments here, with Loach only hinting to the wider forces that divide society (at one point, Blake stands ironically in front of a jewellery store window with the meaningless slogan ‘Love’ emblazoned across the expensive products). This cinematic verity provides a starkness to certain scenes, such as the aforementioned breakdown, that both unexpectedly shock yet never distance or distort our sympathies. Conversely, it is more intimate, it brings us closer. In attempting to bring all the charges against austerity without losing the focus on Blake and Katie, Loach only makes reference to the bedroom tax, zero hours contracts, persecution of the disabled and youth unemployment which come across as hastily-added snatches of dialogue than properly developed subplots.

In true Brechtian fashion, Loach and Laverty are unapologetically didactic when dramatising the Coalition and Conservative government’s legacy of welfare measures. While beginning with the patronising, absurd questions that infantilises Blake, the film ends clearly with a declaration of his humanity. As with Blake’s act of protest in the film, I, Daniel Blake is an assertion of person-hood, a cry against the state forces that are denigrating thousands of people and a call to recognise their right to dignity. This film is a necessary portrait of those bearing the brunt of an economic ideology and political policy that provides only further impoverishment, alienation and despair. As with his previous films, Cathy Come Home and Kes, Loach provides and leaves us with a quiet anger, a moral outrage that demands our active participation in the forgotten (though frankly speaking discarded) pursuit of social justice. I, Daniel Blake is, indeed, a work of fiction. If only it were so fictional and so far from those current realities the film unfalteringly depicts.

3 comments on “I, Daniel Blake | Review

  1. This film has arrived at an interesting time in terms of the world’s ideological swing to the right. Was this anticipated by Ken Loach? Great review.

    Liked by 1 person

    • James Humphrey

      From what I understand about Loach, he’s been witness (as have we all) to the massive political and economic paradigm shift that has moved us from the post-war social democratic settlement to neoliberalism, with the state being reduced to merely an enabler of free-market capitalism. Considering China, capitalism seems to be able to co-exist with state authoritarianism without much problem. The only difference in the last few years is how openly authoritarian and more far right-wing ideologically governments are becoming in the Western world (see Poland, Italy, Hungary, UK and the US to name a few). I’d check out Loach’s documentary ‘Spirit of ’45’ (which I think doesn’t think is analytical enough but you get the essence of what has changed). What I think was truly brilliant and unique about I, Daniel Blake is how relevant it is- this is a rare depiction of living under austerity politics in the UK. There should be so many films and television programmes covering this, as Loach, Alan Bleasdale and Mike Leigh did in the 60s/70s/80s (closest other than Loach is Shane Meadows really) but you just don’t see it. Thanks for the support!

      Liked by 1 person

      • Re your comment about “how openly authoritarian and more far right-wing ideologically governments are becoming in the Western world”, we are seeing this in Australia and its happening at a frightening pace. Its also accompanied by a new conservative political correctness: ie: if you object to the alt-right extremisms you need to be drained from the swamp. As as film critic, I await the first movie about the new world order; maybe a name like “A Man Called Adolf” with orange hair.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

fishnet cinema

film, according to women and femmes

Bully Bloggers

the queer bully pulpit you never dreamed of....

kathydasilva

Art and writing and reviews...

CineMuseFilms

Freelance Film Critic

The Wannabe Film Critic

Where We Shake A Stick At Hollywood And Beyond

Jordan and Eddie (The Movie Guys)

Australia based film fans - Like Margaret and David, only so much younger

%d bloggers like this: